Legal advice also available in English.
vitaly gariev lllzksmxe7a unsplash

Can my employer dismiss me because of illness in Germany?

A long illness is a difficult time. For many employees it comes with a second worry: losing their job. One of the questions I am asked most often is therefore: can my employer dismiss me because I am ill? In this article I explain under which conditions a dismissal due to illness (krankheitsbedingte Kündigung) is possible in Germany, what rights you have as an employee and how you can protect yourself.

I am Peter Lamprecht, a lawyer in Würzburg, and I advise employees on German employment law, also in English.

This article covers German employment law only.

No automatic dismissal because of illness

In principle, German employment law protects employees from being dismissed because of illness. Being ill is not a breach of contract, and a dismissal is not a punishment for it. A dismissal due to illness is only permitted if certain conditions are met. It is based on operational necessity: the illness must affect the business so severely that there is no other solution.

If you have worked for your employer for more than six months and the business regularly employs more than ten employees, the Dismissal Protection Act (Section 1 KSchG, in German) applies. The dismissal must then be socially justified. Whether this is the case is decided by the labour courts on the basis of a careful weighing of interests, in which medical prognoses, the effects on the business and your individual circumstances all play a decisive role.

The three-stage test for a dismissal due to illness

The case law has developed three requirements. All three must be met for a dismissal due to illness to be valid:

  • A negative health prognosis. It must be likely that your health problems will continue to lead to absences or reduced performance in future.
  • A considerable impairment of the business. The absences or the reduced performance must place a noticeable burden on the business or cause economic harm.
  • A weighing of interests and no milder means. The employer must consider whether dismissal is proportionate or whether milder measures, such as moving you to a different role or adapting your tasks, are possible.

Only if all three requirements are met can the dismissal be valid.

What does a negative health prognosis mean?

A negative prognosis exists if, based on medical findings and your previous medical history, further absences are to be expected or a lasting reduction in performance exists. A vague assumption is not sufficient; there must be a well-founded assessment.

The case law does not set a fixed minimum length of expected illness. However, most labour courts expect a negative prognosis to relate to illnesses that are likely to cause permanent or recurring incapacity for work for at least another year.

Typical examples are chronic illnesses with uncertain prospects of recovery or long illnesses that keep recurring. A single or short illness does not usually lead to a negative prognosis. Even frequent short absences only lead to a negative prognosis in extreme cases, for example if an employee has been absent on most working days over a period of several years.

For you as an employee, good medical documentation that explains your situation is important.

When is the business considerably impaired?

The employer must prove that the illness causes a considerable disadvantage for the business. What matters is the extent and frequency of the absences, how severely performance is reduced and whether someone can cover for you.

In small businesses, absences can become a problem more quickly than in large companies with many employees. The type of work also matters: it is harder to replace someone in a key position than someone doing simpler tasks. Mere inconvenience or extra work for colleagues is not enough to justify a dismissal.

Milder means and integration management (BEM)

Before your employer may dismiss you, it must check whether there are milder means. These can include:

  • moving you to a different workplace,
  • adjusting your working hours,
  • changing your duties,
  • an occupational integration management procedure (betriebliches Eingliederungsmanagement, BEM).

If you have been unable to work for more than six weeks within one year, either continuously or in total, your employer must offer you a BEM procedure under Section 167 of Book IX of the Social Code (SGB IX, in German). The aim is to overcome your incapacity for work, prevent new absences and keep your job. Taking part is voluntary for you, but you should take the offer seriously. Employers must document which measures they considered and why these were not sufficient.

In practice, the BEM is often decisive. If an employer dismisses you due to illness without having offered a proper BEM, it will usually find it very hard to show in court that there was no milder means than dismissal.

Special protection for certain groups

Pregnant employees, mothers on maternity leave, employees on parental leave and severely disabled employees enjoy special protection against dismissal. Stricter rules apply, and the approval of a public authority is often required before the employer may dismiss. Members of the works council are also specially protected. These rules are meant to prevent particularly vulnerable people from being put at a disadvantage because of their situation.

If you belong to one of these groups, you should definitely have a lawyer check whether to challenge the dismissal. And remember: you only have three weeks.

Formal requirements and deadlines

A dismissal must be in writing, signed by hand, and must respect the statutory or contractual notice periods. Most importantly for you: once you have received the dismissal, you have only three weeks to file an unfair dismissal claim. If you miss this deadline, the dismissal is generally treated as valid. My article on the unfair dismissal claim in Germany explains this deadline in detail.

If there is a works council (Betriebsrat), it must be heard before every dismissal under Section 102 of the Works Constitution Act (official English translation). A dismissal issued without a proper hearing is invalid. Errors in such formalities can therefore decide the case.

Tips if you are facing a dismissal due to illness

  • Stay calm and read the dismissal carefully.
  • Collect your medical documents and any prognoses from your doctors.
  • Check whether your employer offered you a BEM procedure.
  • Contact the works council early, if there is one.
  • Get legal advice from an employment lawyer.
  • Keep the three-week deadline for an unfair dismissal claim in mind. It runs from the day you receive the dismissal letter.
  • Document your own efforts to return to work.

By acting early, you improve your chances of keeping your job or of obtaining a fair severance payment.

Costs of legal support

Many legal expenses insurance policies (Rechtsschutzversicherung) cover the costs of an employment dispute in full or in large part. To be covered, the policy must include employment law and must usually have existed for more than three months before you received the dismissal.

An important special rule applies before the German labour courts: in the first instance, each side bears its own lawyer’s fees, regardless of the outcome. The losing party pays the court fees. If the case ends with a settlement in court, no court fees are charged at all.

If you do not have legal expenses insurance, you can often apply for legal aid (Prozesskostenhilfe), in which case the state covers your lawyer’s fees. The requirement is that your income is relatively low and your necessary expenses, such as rent or children, are relatively high. Whether this is an option for you is something I explain in a personal consultation. The third option is that you pay the costs yourself. The amount depends on your most recent salary. In an unfair dismissal case, lawyer’s fees usually lie between €1,500 and €3,500. An initial consultation in my office costs between €50 for 15 minutes and €190 for up to one hour, plus VAT.

Prospects of success

The prospects depend on the individual case, in particular on whether all three requirements for a dismissal due to illness are met. Because the hurdles for employers are high, employees often have good prospects of successfully challenging such a dismissal. Many of these cases therefore end with a settlement and a severance payment. As a rule, the longer the employment has lasted, the higher the severance. My article on severance pay in Germany explains what is realistic.

Conclusion

A dismissal due to illness is possible in Germany, but only after a careful examination of all the circumstances and with the special protection of ill employees in mind. If you have been dismissed due to illness or expect to be, act quickly: keep your sick notes and medical records, use the BEM procedure and seek advice early.

If you work in Würzburg or Lower Franconia, I am happy to advise you on your individual situation in English. Find out more on my page about legal advice in English or visit the homepage of my law office.

This article provides general information on German employment law and does not replace advice on your individual case.

Frequently asked questions

Can I be dismissed while I am on sick leave in Germany?

Yes, being on sick leave does not in itself protect you from dismissal. However, a dismissal due to illness is only valid if there is a negative health prognosis, a considerable impairment of the business and no milder means. The three-week deadline for a claim also runs during sick leave.

What is a BEM procedure?

BEM stands for betriebliches Eingliederungsmanagement, an occupational integration management procedure. Your employer must offer it if you have been unable to work for more than six weeks within one year. It aims to keep your job and prevent further absences. Taking part is voluntary.

Is a dismissal due to illness valid without a BEM procedure?

Not automatically invalid, but the employer will find it very hard to prove that there was no milder means than dismissal. In practice, a missing BEM procedure is often a strong argument for the employee in court.

How long do I have to challenge a dismissal due to illness?

Three weeks from receiving the dismissal letter. If you miss this deadline, the dismissal is generally treated as valid, even if it was unjustified. Get advice as early as possible.

Will my legal expenses insurance cover an unfair dismissal claim?

Often, yes, if the policy includes employment law and existed for more than three months before you received the dismissal. In the first instance before the labour court, each side otherwise bears its own lawyer’s fees, regardless of the outcome.

More articles in English

0931 470 85 337
Kostenlose Ersteinschätzung
Kostenlos & unverbindlich · Antwort meist am selben Werktag