After a dismissal, the employment reference (Arbeitszeugnis) is a final but decisive step for many employees. In Germany it accompanies job applications for years and helps to decide what your next career move looks like. It is all the more annoying when your former employer does not issue a reference at all, delivers it too late or chooses an assessment that does not reflect your actual performance.
I am Peter Lamprecht, a lawyer in Würzburg, and I advise employees on German employment law, also in English. In this article I explain what rights you have regarding your employment reference, which issues typically lead to disputes before the labour court, when a claim really pays off and how to proceed strategically to obtain a fair assessment.
This article covers German employment law only.
Why the reference matters so much in Germany
If you have worked in other countries, you may be used to short reference letters or to a former manager simply being called by a new employer. In Germany, the written employment reference is a standard part of almost every job application. Recruiters read it closely, and they are familiar with its coded language. A reference that sounds friendly to you may in fact contain a mediocre grade. This is why it is worth taking a close look.
The right to an employment reference
Every employee has a right to a written employment reference under Section 109 of the Trade Regulation Act (GewO, in German), regardless of why the employment ended. The German Civil Code refers to the same rule in Section 630 (official English translation). The right arises at the latest when the employment ends, and it is directed against the employer, not against individual managers.
The reference must be clearly worded, written in the usual business form, printed on company letterhead and signed by the employer or a person authorised to represent it. A reference sent only by email or fax is not sufficient.
Simple and qualified reference
The law distinguishes between two forms. A simple reference (einfaches Zeugnis) only contains information about you and the work you did. A qualified reference (qualifiziertes Zeugnis) also assesses your performance and conduct during the employment. In almost all cases you should ask for a qualified reference: only this makes for a meaningful job application.
Make it clear which form you want, ideally in writing. If you do not ask for a qualified reference, the employer only owes you a simple one at first.
What a qualified reference must contain
A qualified reference has a fairly fixed structure. The labour courts expect in particular:
- your personal details and a precise description of your work,
- statements on your expertise, working methods, resilience and results,
- an overall assessment of your performance, for example “stets zu unserer vollen Zufriedenheit” (always to our full satisfaction),
- an assessment of your conduct towards superiors, colleagues and, where relevant, customers,
- a closing formula with thanks, regret at your departure and good wishes for the future.
A qualified reference without these elements is often considered incomplete, and you can ask for it to be corrected.
Understanding the coded language
Employment references must be worded benevolently and at the same time be truthful. This tension has created a special coded language (Zeugnissprache) whose meaning many employees do not recognise immediately. Seemingly friendly phrases often conceal specific grades, similar to school grades.
The following scale gives a rough guide:
- “stets zu unserer vollsten Zufriedenheit” (always to our fullest satisfaction): very good
- “stets zu unserer vollen Zufriedenheit” (always to our full satisfaction): good
- “zu unserer vollen Zufriedenheit” (to our full satisfaction): satisfactory
- “zu unserer Zufriedenheit” (to our satisfaction): adequate
- “im Großen und Ganzen zu unserer Zufriedenheit” (on the whole to our satisfaction): poor
In addition, there are individual phrases that work like a secret code in practice: they create the impression of a positive reference while hiding weaknesses. If in doubt, have your reference checked by a lawyer.
Why references so often lead to disputes
Employment references are a classic case before the labour courts, for several reasons. They often follow a difficult end to the employment. A good reference is also of considerable economic value for your future career. And the coded language makes it possible to wrap criticism in such a way that the employee only notices it late.
This is why it is often worth not simply accepting a reference but checking it critically and asking for corrections where necessary, if need be in court.
Typical points of dispute
Before the labour court, the following points are typically at the centre of the dispute:
- the overall grade, where employees often sue for a better assessment,
- the assessment of conduct, especially if not all groups (superiors, colleagues, customers where relevant) are mentioned,
- the job description, and whether it is complete and reflects your actual position,
- the closing formula, since missing thanks and regret can reduce the value of the reference,
- suspicious omissions or ambiguous wording that devalue the reference as a whole.
For each of these points it can be worthwhile to have the matter checked by a lawyer and to ask for corrections.
The right to a benevolent reference
A reference must be worded in such a way that it does not unfairly hinder your career. It should be benevolent but truthful. Negative assessments are not ruled out, but they must be objectively justified and expressed in the usual form.
An assessment that is far below the usual level for the industry and the type of work, without a clear factual basis, can be challenged successfully. General statements such as “did not meet our expectations” without concrete facts are not permitted in many cases.
Who has to prove what?
The burden of proof is divided. According to the case law of the Federal Labour Court (Bundesarbeitsgericht), you can generally expect a satisfactory grade, “zu unserer vollen Zufriedenheit”. If the employer wants to give you a worse grade, it must set out and prove the facts that justify it.
The reverse is also true: if you want a better grade than satisfactory, such as good or very good, you must set out and, if necessary, prove the facts that support it yourself. Careful preparation with appraisals, target agreements, emails and witnesses is therefore crucial.
When is it worth going to the labour court?
A claim is particularly worthwhile if the reference falls well short of your actual performance, your work is described incorrectly, important elements are missing or suspicious omissions are used. A reference that is refused altogether is also a classic case for a claim.
In many cases the dispute does not end with a judgment but with a settlement. Often the reference is agreed as part of an unfair dismissal claim that is already ongoing. The effort involved in a reference dispute is manageable, the risk is usually predictable, and the economic benefits of a better reference can be considerable.
What can the court order?
The labour court can order the employer to issue a specific reference, to change individual phrases, to add missing elements or to issue a completely new reference. In practice, specific wording is often agreed in a settlement so that both sides know exactly what the outcome will be.
The court only decides on the written assessment, not on the personal conflicts behind it. The legal question is which reference you are entitled to, not a new evaluation of the employment relationship as a whole.
Which deadlines apply?
In reference disputes, so-called exclusion periods (Ausschlussfristen) play a major role. Employment contracts and collective agreements often provide for periods of three or six months within which claims must be asserted in writing and, in some cases, then in court.
Even without an express deadline, the right to a reference or to its correction can be forfeited if you wait too long. If you are not happy with your reference, react quickly, ask for corrections in writing and get legal advice if in doubt, so that you do not miss any deadlines.
Solutions out of court
Not every reference dispute has to go to court. Often a structured letter from a lawyer is enough, naming the disputed points specifically and asking for a correction within a reasonable deadline. Many employers are willing to adjust the reference to avoid a further conflict.
The wording of the reference can also be agreed in writing in advance as part of a termination agreement or a settlement after a dismissal. This gives you a reliable result without further court proceedings.
Practical tips
If you want to obtain a fair reference around the time of a dismissal, keep the following in mind:
- Collect appraisals, emails praising your work and achieved targets while you are still employed.
- Ask for a qualified reference in writing whenever your employment ends.
- Check the reference carefully for coded language, completeness and form.
- Ask for corrections in writing, specifically and with a deadline.
- Keep any exclusion periods in your employment contract or collective agreement in mind.
- If an unfair dismissal claim is ongoing, include the reference directly in the settlement.
- In case of a dispute, involve an employment lawyer early.
In this way you not only avoid mistakes but in many cases achieve a considerably better assessment than your employer originally intended.
Conclusion
The employment reference is more than a piece of paper: in Germany it often influences your professional future. If you receive an incomplete, incorrect or poorly graded reference after a dismissal, you should not simply accept it. Your right to a benevolent, truthful and correctly worded reference is laid down in law and can be enforced before the labour court if necessary. Often a correction can be achieved out of court, and in an unfair dismissal case the reference can usually be settled at the same time. React early and keep an eye on the deadlines.
If you work in Würzburg or Lower Franconia, I am happy to check your reference and advise you on your individual situation in English. Find out more on my page about legal advice in English or visit the homepage of my law office.
This article provides general information on German employment law and does not replace advice on your individual case.
Frequently asked questions
Which grade can I expect in my German employment reference?
According to the case law, you can generally expect at least a satisfactory grade, worded as zu unserer vollen Zufriedenheit. If your employer wants to give a worse grade, it must prove the facts that justify it. If you want a better grade, you must set out and prove the facts that support it yourself.
What can I do if my reference is poor or incorrect?
First, check it carefully for completeness and coded language. Then ask your employer in writing for specific corrections, ideally with a deadline. If the employer refuses, a claim before the labour court is possible. Often a letter from a lawyer is enough to resolve the dispute out of court.
Is there a deadline for asking for a better reference?
Often yes. Many employment contracts and collective agreements contain exclusion periods of three or six months. In addition, the right can be forfeited if you wait too long. Ask for corrections soon after receiving the reference.
What is the difference between a simple and a qualified reference?
A simple reference only describes you and the work you did. A qualified reference also assesses your performance and conduct. For job applications in Germany you should almost always ask for a qualified reference, and you have to request it actively.
Can the reference be included in a settlement after a dismissal?
Yes, and this is very common. If you have filed an unfair dismissal claim, the wording or at least the overall grade of the reference can be agreed in the settlement. This gives you certainty about the result without separate proceedings.



