Legal advice also available in English.
sebastian herrmann ili1gmb9jes unsplash

Redundancy in Germany: when your job is cut for operational reasons

A drop in orders, a restructuring, the closure of a department or of an entire site: the reasons for a dismissal for operational reasons (betriebsbedingte Kündigung), often called redundancy, are many. For the employees affected it is usually a double shock. They lose their job even though there was nothing wrong with their own performance. This is exactly why German law makes the validity of such a dismissal subject to particularly strict requirements.

I am Peter Lamprecht, a lawyer in Würzburg, and I advise employees on German employment law, also in English. In this article I explain what a dismissal for operational reasons is, which requirements it must meet, when the social selection is correct, how much severance you can expect and which steps you should take now.

This article covers German employment law only.

What is a dismissal for operational reasons?

A dismissal for operational reasons is an ordinary dismissal with notice that the employer issues because of urgent operational requirements. Unlike a dismissal for reasons of conduct or for personal reasons, the cause does not lie in the employee’s person or behaviour but in the economic or organisational situation of the company.

It is expressly provided for in Section 1 of the Dismissal Protection Act (KSchG, in German). The Act applies if you have worked for the employer for more than six months and the business regularly employs more than ten employees. The key requirement is that the need for your work has genuinely disappeared and there is no other way of continuing to employ you in the company. Only then may the employer resort to dismissal.

Requirements for a valid dismissal for operational reasons

For a dismissal for operational reasons to stand up in court, several requirements must be met at the same time:

  • There are urgent operational requirements that lead to jobs being cut.
  • The loss of the job is permanent. Short-term fluctuations are not enough.
  • There is no reasonable way of continuing to employ you in another vacant position.
  • The social selection (Sozialauswahl) has been carried out correctly.
  • The works council (Betriebsrat), if there is one, has been properly consulted.

If just one of these requirements is missing, the dismissal can be invalid. This is exactly where unfair dismissal claims most often start in practice.

External and internal reasons

The operational requirements can come from outside or from within the company. External reasons include a lasting drop in orders, the loss of important customers or changes in the law that make the existing business more difficult. Internal reasons are business decisions, such as a restructuring, the closure of a department or the outsourcing of certain tasks.

In both cases the employer must be able to show in a comprehensible way why your job has disappeared. The court only reviews this decision to a limited extent, however: the employer’s freedom to run the business as it sees fit is generally respected.

The business decision

At the heart of every dismissal for operational reasons is the so-called business decision (unternehmerische Entscheidung). The court does not check whether it makes economic sense, only whether it is obviously unfounded, unreasonable or arbitrary. This gives the employer a wide margin, but it does not rule out abuse.

What matters is that the decision is actually implemented. An employer who dismisses someone because the position has supposedly been cut, and shortly afterwards gives the same work to a newly hired person, risks the dismissal being regarded as an abuse of rights.

No more need for your work

The specific need for your work must have disappeared, meaning the job itself or at least the work connected with it. Simply redistributing tasks or dropping individual projects is not automatically enough.

What counts is a careful forecast. Can the employer plausibly assume that your work will no longer be needed in the long term? Are there vacant positions in the company that you could fill, if necessary after reasonable training? Only if the answers to these questions are negative is dismissal the last resort.

Continued employment comes first

In German employment law, dismissal is always the last resort (ultima ratio). Before every dismissal, the employer must check whether milder measures would be sufficient, for example a transfer to another department, a change in working conditions or a dismissal with an offer of altered terms (Änderungskündigung) instead of ending the employment altogether. Reducing overtime or the use of agency workers can also make a dismissal for operational reasons unnecessary.

If the employer fails to carry out this check or ignores obvious alternatives, the dismissal is usually invalid, which is an important starting point for an unfair dismissal claim.

The social selection: the core of the case

If only some of several comparable jobs are cut, the social selection is decisive. It is meant to ensure that, among comparable employees, those who are least in need of social protection are dismissed first. Under Section 1(3) KSchG, four criteria are decisive:

  • length of service,
  • age,
  • maintenance obligations, especially towards children or a spouse,
  • severe disability.

The employer must document the selection in a comprehensible way and, if you ask, tell you which employees were included in the comparison and on what basis the decision was made. Errors in the social selection are among the most common reasons why dismissals for operational reasons fail in court.

Who is excluded from the social selection?

Certain employees can be left out of the social selection if keeping them is in the legitimate interest of the business because of their particular knowledge, skills or performance. The employer must, however, give concrete reasons for excluding such key employees and prove them in the event of a dispute.

In addition, certain groups enjoy special protection against dismissal, for example pregnant employees, employees on parental leave, severely disabled employees and members of the works council. For them, a dismissal for operational reasons is only possible under very narrow conditions and in some cases only with the approval of a public authority.

Consultation of the works council

If there is a works council, it must be properly consulted before every dismissal under Section 102 of the Works Constitution Act (official English translation). This of course also applies to a dismissal for operational reasons. The employer must give the works council all relevant information: the reasons, the jobs affected, the social data and the considerations behind the selection.

According to settled case law, a dismissal issued without proper consultation is invalid. The works council can raise concerns, object to the dismissal or agree to it. Its objection can also give you a right to continued employment while the court proceedings are ongoing.

Collective redundancies

If several employees are dismissed at the same time as part of a restructuring, the employer may have to notify the employment agency (Agentur für Arbeit) of collective redundancies (Massenentlassungsanzeige). The thresholds depend on the size of the business and the number of employees affected. If the notification is not made or is defective, the dismissals are also invalid.

In businesses with a works council, a social plan (Sozialplan) is also often negotiated. It can provide for severance payments, transitional benefits or training measures for the employees affected and can considerably soften the effects of a dismissal for operational reasons.

Am I entitled to severance pay?

There is no general statutory right to severance pay (Abfindung) in German employment law. In practice, however, severance payments are very common, whether under a social plan, a termination agreement or a settlement after an unfair dismissal claim.

Section 1a KSchG (in German) contains a special rule: if the employer offers severance in the dismissal letter on condition that you do not file an unfair dismissal claim, you are entitled to half a gross monthly salary per year of service once the deadline has passed. Through a claim or skilful negotiation, however, considerably higher amounts can often be achieved. My article on severance pay in Germany explains what is realistic.

Deadlines you must know

If you receive a dismissal for operational reasons, you must file an unfair dismissal claim with the labour court within three weeks of receiving it. Otherwise the dismissal is treated as valid, even if it could have been challenged on its merits. My article on the unfair dismissal claim in Germany explains this deadline in detail.

In addition, you must register as looking for work with the employment agency in good time: as a rule, within three days of receiving the dismissal if your employment ends in less than three months. If you register late, a short blocking period (Sperrzeit) can apply to your unemployment benefit. Both deadlines run independently of each other and must be kept at the same time.

Unfair dismissal claim and prospects of success

The aim of an unfair dismissal claim is to have the court declare the dismissal invalid so that the employment continues. In practice, many cases end with a settlement providing for severance and the end of the employment by agreement. In cases of dismissal for operational reasons in particular, the prospects are often good: it is not unusual to be able to show that the social selection, the consultation of the works council or the explanation of the business decision was flawed.

A serious assessment of your prospects, however, requires a careful examination of the specific circumstances by an employment lawyer. General statements are not possible, so if you want a well-founded assessment, you should get legal advice early.

Will I lose unemployment benefit?

A blocking period for unemployment benefit is usually only imposed if you ended the employment yourself or caused its end through your own fault. If your employer dismisses you for operational reasons, there is generally no blocking period, provided you did not actively bring about the end of the employment yourself.

Accepting severance as part of a settlement in court does not usually lead to a blocking period either. The situation can be different with a termination agreement (Aufhebungsvertrag), so particular care is needed before you sign one. My article on the termination agreement in Germany explains the risks.

Practical tips

If you receive a dismissal for operational reasons, you should act in a structured and swift way:

  • Check the dismissal letter immediately: date, written form, handwritten signature and reasons.
  • Mark the three-week deadline for the unfair dismissal claim in your calendar.
  • Register as looking for work with the employment agency within three days.
  • Do not sign a termination agreement or settlement agreement in a hurry.
  • Ask your employer for information on the social selection, vacant positions and the consultation of the works council.
  • Contact an employment lawyer early to assess your prospects and the potential for severance realistically.

Good preparation improves not only your chances of keeping your job but also of obtaining a considerably higher severance payment.

Conclusion

A dismissal for operational reasons is not a formality for the employer. It requires urgent operational needs, the permanent loss of the job, no possibility of continued employment, a correct social selection and, where there is a works council, its proper consultation. If you receive such a dismissal, do not simply accept it but have it checked in time. Your chances of either keeping your job or negotiating appropriate severance are often good. Above all, act quickly: the three-week deadline is unforgiving.

If you work in Würzburg or Lower Franconia, I am happy to advise you on your individual situation in English. Find out more on my page about legal advice in English or visit the homepage of my law office.

This article provides general information on German employment law and does not replace advice on your individual case.

Frequently asked questions

When is a dismissal for operational reasons lawful in Germany?

Only if urgent operational requirements permanently remove the need for your work, there is no reasonable way of employing you in another vacant position, the social selection was carried out correctly and the works council, if there is one, was properly consulted. If one of these requirements is missing, the dismissal is usually invalid.

What is the social selection?

If only some of several comparable jobs are cut, the employer must choose the employees who are least in need of social protection. The four criteria are length of service, age, maintenance obligations and severe disability. Errors in the social selection are one of the most common reasons why such dismissals fail in court.

Am I entitled to severance pay after a redundancy in Germany?

There is no general statutory right to severance pay. In practice, however, severance is very common, for example under a social plan or in a settlement after an unfair dismissal claim. If the employer offers severance under Section 1a KSchG, it amounts to half a gross monthly salary per year of service.

Which deadlines do I have to meet after a dismissal for operational reasons?

You must file an unfair dismissal claim within three weeks of receiving the dismissal. Separately, you must register as looking for work with the employment agency, as a rule within three days if your employment ends in less than three months. Both deadlines run in parallel.

Will I get unemployment benefit after a redundancy?

Usually yes. If your employer dismisses you for operational reasons and you did not bring about the end of the employment yourself, there is generally no blocking period. A settlement in court is normally unproblematic, while a termination agreement should be checked carefully before you sign.

More articles in English

0931 470 85 337
Kostenlose Ersteinschätzung
Kostenlos & unverbindlich · Antwort meist am selben Werktag