Receiving a written warning from your employer is an unpleasant experience. In German, it is called an Abmahnung: a formal reprimand stating that your conduct or performance does not meet your obligations under the employment contract. It is usually placed in your personnel file. A warning has no direct consequences at first, but if the same kind of conduct happens again, it can lead to much more serious consequences, including dismissal.
For international employees, a warning can be particularly confusing, because the concept does not exist in the same form everywhere and the letter is usually written in German. In this article I explain when a warning is valid, when you should take action against it and when it is better to accept it. I also give you some practical tips on how to respond.
This article covers German employment law only.
What is the purpose of a written warning?
At first glance, the purpose is simple: your employer wants you to comply with your contract in future.
There is a second purpose, and it is the more important one. If your employer later wants to dismiss you for misconduct (verhaltensbedingte Kündigung), this dismissal almost always requires a prior valid warning for similar misconduct. German law treats dismissal as a last resort. For contracts of continuing obligation, the German Civil Code expressly requires a warning before termination for a breach of contract in most cases, see Section 314 of the German Civil Code (official English translation). Only in exceptional cases, for example with very serious breaches such as theft, can an employer dismiss without a prior warning, often by way of a summary dismissal without notice.
This is why a warning matters more than it might seem. It is often the employer’s preparation for a later dismissal.
When is a written warning valid?
For a warning to be legally valid, several requirements must be met:
- A specific breach of contract. The employer must be able to prove a specific breach of contract or misconduct, for example refusing to work, repeatedly arriving late, theft or rudeness towards customers. The courts expect precision: the warning must describe the conduct as exactly as possible, with dates and details. A vague accusation such as “your attitude to work is unacceptable” is not enough, and the warning is then invalid.
- Reprimand and warning function. A valid warning has two elements. It must point out the misconduct clearly (the reprimand function, Rügefunktion), and it must warn you that a repetition will have consequences for your employment (the warning function, Warnfunktion). A letter that only criticises you without mentioning possible consequences is a mere reprimand (Ermahnung). It cannot prepare a later dismissal.
- Written form is not mandatory. A warning does not have to be in writing. In practice, however, an oral warning is very difficult or even impossible for the employer to prove, because it would have to prove that both functions were fulfilled. Even with witnesses, this is hard, because who remembers the exact wording weeks or months later? For this reason, a written warning is the only sensible approach for employers.
- Proportionality. The warning must be proportionate to the seriousness of the misconduct. A warning for arriving five minutes late through no fault of your own, for example, would be disproportionate.
- Timing. The employer must issue the warning within a reasonable time after the incident. However, neither the law nor the case law sets a fixed period. According to the Federal Labour Court (Bundesarbeitsgericht), this depends on the circumstances of the individual case.
- How long a warning remains effective. There is no general rule on how long a warning remains effective either. A warning does not automatically lose its effect after two or three years. Again, it depends on the circumstances of the individual case.
If these requirements are not met, the warning may be invalid, and you can take action against it. The real question, however, is whether and when you should.
When should you challenge a written warning?
There are a number of situations in which it can make sense to take action:
- Formal defects. The formal requirements described above are not met, for example the warning contains wrong dates, you never actually received it, or the reprimand or warning function is missing.
- Defects in substance. The employer has not described the alleged breach properly, has described it incorrectly, or the warning is disproportionate.
- Wrong facts or an unfair assessment. The employer’s account of what happened is simply wrong, or the employer has judged the situation in a clearly one-sided way.
- Repeated warnings. If you have received several warnings, perhaps ones you consider unfair, even though you are doing your best, another warning can be a sign that a dismissal is being prepared. In that situation, it is advisable to seek legal advice.
When is it better to accept a written warning?
In some cases it is wiser to accept a warning rather than to fight it:
- A clear breach of contract. If your conduct or performance really did breach your contract and your employer can prove it, it is usually better to accept the warning and avoid such mistakes in future.
- Minor misconduct. If the misconduct is minor, such as arriving late once, legal action can do more harm than good. Accepting the warning is often more sensible than going to court.
- Your relationship with your employer. If you generally have a good relationship with your employer and the warning is not personally motivated, a dispute over it can damage trust.
- An expected dismissal. Sometimes a warning is the forerunner of a dismissal. If you receive a warning that is very probably invalid, it often makes more sense not to sue for its removal from your personnel file. Instead, you wait and challenge the expected dismissal for misconduct in court, because a dismissal that is based on an invalid warning is generally invalid as well. If you sue now, you give your employer the chance to correct its mistakes and issue a new, valid warning.
In the end, the decision is yours. If in doubt, get advice from an employment lawyer before you react.
How can you take action against a written warning?
You have two direct options.
Option 1: a written response (Gegenvorstellung)
You can set out your view of what happened in writing and send it to your employer. Under Section 83 of the Works Constitution Act (official English translation), you are entitled to inspect your personnel file and to have your own statement added to it. Your employer must place your response in the file alongside the warning, regardless of whose account is correct.
This makes sense above all if your employer has completely misunderstood the facts. Describe what actually happened as precisely as possible and name anyone who can confirm your account. Stay factual and avoid accusations: your response may later be read by a judge.
Option 2: a claim for removal from the personnel file
You can also ask the labour court (Arbeitsgericht) to order your employer to remove the warning from your personnel file. To do so, you must explain why the warning is invalid. Sometimes this makes sense, sometimes it does not. In particular, consider the strategic point above: if a dismissal is likely, it is often better to keep your arguments for the dismissal case.
Practical tips if you receive a written warning
- Stay calm and do not react in anger, either in writing or in conversation.
- Do not sign anything that confirms the accusations. At most, sign to confirm that you have received the letter.
- Note down your own account of events while your memory is fresh, and keep any emails, rotas or messages that support it.
- If there is a works council (Betriebsrat), you can involve it.
- Get advice before you send a written response or take any legal steps.
If you have already been dismissed, act quickly: you have only three weeks to file a claim. My article on the unfair dismissal claim in Germany explains the deadline, and my article on severance pay explains how such cases often end.
Conclusion
A written warning is always unpleasant. Whether you should take action against it depends on the circumstances of your case. Have an employment lawyer check carefully whether the warning is valid and what the right reaction is. Whatever you decide, approach the situation calmly and factually.
If you work in Würzburg or Lower Franconia and have received a warning, I am happy to review it with you in English and help you find the right strategy. More information is available on my page about legal advice in English and on the homepage of my law office.
This article provides general information on German employment law and does not replace advice on your individual case.
Frequently asked questions
Does a written warning in Germany have to be in writing?
No, an oral warning can also be valid. In practice, however, the employer must prove that the warning clearly described the misconduct and threatened consequences. That is very difficult with an oral warning, so employers almost always issue warnings in writing.
Can I be dismissed without a prior warning?
For a dismissal for misconduct, a prior valid warning for similar conduct is required in almost all cases. Only very serious breaches, such as theft or violence, can justify a dismissal without a warning.
How long does a written warning stay in my personnel file?
There is no fixed period. A warning does not automatically lose its effect after two or three years. Whether it can still support a dismissal depends on the circumstances of the individual case.
Should I sue to have a warning removed from my file?
Not always. If a dismissal is likely, it is often better to wait and challenge the dismissal instead, because a dismissal based on an invalid warning is generally invalid as well. A lawyer can help you choose the right strategy.
Can I add my own statement to my personnel file?
Yes. You are entitled to inspect your personnel file and to have a written statement added to it. Your employer must keep your statement in the file alongside the warning.



